Sunday, August 19, 2007

Lifting the Veil of the Inner Blogologue.

"This will make for a great blog post."
"I am so blogging this."
"Well, at least I got a good blog out of it."

I cringe when I hear these statements. Such hyper-self-awareness makes me uncomfortable. Why? Aaah, because we hate in others that which we loathe in ourselves.

Frequently, more so than I would like to admit, I find myself composing blog posts in my head about an event which I am still in the middle of experiencing. Think of me like Harold Crick, played by Will Ferrell, in "Stranger than Fiction," only my narrator has more of a Southern accent and less of a charming British one. And let me tell you, it is distracting.

A veil of creativity drops before our eyes. We begin to see our
experiences through the thin veil of our blog. We recognize perfect "sound bites." We spot ideal illustrative pictures. We start composing. And if we aren't mindful, we slightly disengage, lost in our own heads.

Perhaps more to the point, then, think of me as Zach Braff's character, Dr. John "J.D." Dorian, on NBC's "Scrubs." While narrating his life in his head, he sometimes gets this faraway look on his face, absorbed in his own self-analysis, and misses what is happening right in front of him. Much to the annoyance of the people around him, I should add. Ahem.

This past Easter was the first with my blog. Toward the end of our family Easter activities, my two year old son began dismembering his very first jumbo chocolate bunny, an occasion worth capturing in photographs for our family album, to be sure. However, as I was snapping away, my husband said to me, under his breath, "You are taking that picture for your blog, aren't you?" I looked up, grateful to see that he was smirking, but felt the warm rush of a blush coming to my face. I was taking this particular picture, a closeup of the gnawed bunny ear, for my blog. Busted.


The first time of many in which I would be busted during an inner blogologue, that being a blog-centric inner monologue.

We all do it. And we can see when others are doing it, too, if we are fortunate enough to be IRL friends with other bloggers, or conventional writers, for that matter. Sometimes they will confirm it outright, other times you can see it in their eyes. They are composing. If we are competitive, we start counter-composing, trying to find the other angle, the more clever turn. If we are credible, we don't start directing.

On the heels of the BlogHer conference, you can almost see it happening in the pictures. You can see the blogging wheels turning. Look at enough Flickr albums and you will begin to recognize the blog-posts-in-progress, as they were at the time. Some bloggers might as well have written the imagined future post titles on their foreheads for future reference.

Is there something disingenuous about this behavior? Does it lend a sense of insincerity to the eventual post when it's not written on the fly at your keyboard? Maybe that is why I blushed when my husband caught me taking pictures for my blog and not solely for our family album. Perhaps on some level, I want my audience to believe that I never consider my blog other than during the moments when I am actually writing. My life and my blog as two separate streams, meeting only during the time that I am writing. But should "writing" be limited to the minutes during which my fingers are tapping keys?

Frequently, we come across blog posts about the internet connection of a fellow blogger having been down and that blogger having gone a little cabin-feverish with unwritten blog posts mounting in their heads as their usual outlet is unavailable. The blog infiltrates, the veil drops. And we compose.

All of the previous questions aside, I know the answer to the following question: Does my inner blogologue cause me to disengage, even a little, from the events I am currently experiencing? The answer is "yes." The veil of creativity lowers and I know I am not in the moment as much as I was only seconds before. Yet, I can't help it. Or I don't want to.

Consider your child's birthday party. You spend hours, if not days, planning every detail. You revel in the excitement and embrace the hopefulness of the anticipation. Then the day comes, the guests arrive, all of your plans begin to fall seemingly effortlessly into place as everyone is clearly enjoying themselves. It would be a shame to forget this day, so you pick up the camera, whether it be your still camera or your video camera, or goodness forbid-- both, and you start trying to capture these magical moments for your (probably largely unaware) toddler.

You pat yourself on the back for the beautiful shots you are catching. You can already see the pride on your spouse's face when you show them your clever angles and perfect moments. You are getting it all down, all the smiles, all the surprises, all of it. Well, all of it except for one small detail: you. Days later, you'll frown when you realize that you aren't in any of the pictures.

Just as the lowering of the blogging veil temporarily separates us from the events about which we plan to write, the lens of the camera can cut us off from that which we are so intent on capturing. Sometimes it is only after the fact that we realize our peripheral vision was more severely inhibited than we noticed at the time. We hear a funny anecdote about that birthday party and think, "Where was I? Oh yeah, I was taking pictures across the room."

The camera limits your vision to what can be seen directly in front of your lens. Your inner blogologue splits your engagement between the event as it is happening in your head and as it is happening in your real life. Can you not write your life and live it, too?

The opposite could be argued, however. You could say that knowing that you are going to write about something in your blog gives you a different perspective as you are experiencing it, allowing you to see it from different angles. Something that might normally push you over the edge loses some of its own edge because you can see the humor in the situation, as it will be written. Hell, you might even reenact some of it so that you can catch that picture that will send the post right over into hilarity. That is, if you don't just grab your camera as it is happening. All for the sake of the blog. And maybe a bit of your sanity. Yes, an argument I can understand.

More than ever, we are living in our own heads. The crazy thing is that by doing so, we are consequently engaging with others more than ever. What would have been a funny story between you and your spouse is now a funny story between you, your spouse, and your audience. Do we sacrifice an amount of our engagement for a later prolonged enjoyment of the event? Possibly, though not deliberately. Is that a negative thing? You tell me.

The next time the veil of your inner blogologue begins to lower, take notice. Do you stop it? Do you embrace it? Does anyone else notice? Are you embarrassed if they do? Does this, overall, enhance our experiences in the long run?

Just as I am grateful for our albums full of photographs, albeit mostly without me in them, I know I will be grateful for my blog years from now. Sacrifices of time and engagement be damned. Lower the veil again so that I may see and record and remember.

* * * * * * *
Velveteen Mind

31 comments:

Suburban Oblivion said...

I think it's just the nature of the writer to always be looking for the next story to tell. I don't pretend to sit down and the words just come, if anything I don't sit down until I am composing the post in my head. Writing is not just putting the words on page, it's putting yourself into the words, that is what gives us our voices.

jen said...

i don't have time to comment as long as i'd like but i so love this. i love this next layer of the onion exploration.

Lori at Spinning Yellow said...

I am composing posts in my mind all. the. time. But the truth is that most of what I think about never makes it into my blog. This kind of inner dialog is the way I've always experienced things. Re-telling the story my way even as it is happening. Now that I have a blog I have scribbled pieces of paper of quotes and "scenes" to be written up. These are collecting as time goes by too quickly to record it all.

I liken it to being on vacation and always looking for the perfect photo to capture the event instead of just living in the moment.

Perfect example of being behind the camera and of Zach from Scrubs (Love him!).

I know it is not healthy but I don't think I can be any different. Just like the photographer who captures the person being shot instead of stopping the accident. There is a piece of me that will always be looking for the story instead of experiencing it fully.

slouching mom said...

I'm echoing suburban oblivion as I wonder whether this isn't exclusive to bloggers but true of writers more generally.

Julie Pippert said...

Of course I do this. The difference is I have *always* done it...long before blogging, long before the Internet even.

I always carry small notebooks and pens and have been known at random moments to have my mind caught on an idea that I quickly jot down.

My notebooks are well-known by those who know me well. :)

It does both lift and insert a veil, but this is how I am made, I think. It allows a certain insight into self and situation, I believe.

Like you said, all of us do it in some way, be it photographing an event for posterity or mentally stepping back and viewing the event through a narrative lens.

And I'm not sure that this is any less in the moment or less experiential. It's my experience.

I'll have to think on that.

Julie
Ravin' Picture Maven

gingajoy said...

VM, You have articulated so many of my own thoughts on this one, and I think your piece is a very interesting companion to Bon's--in other words, this is precisely why, at times, it's good to be unplugged. For me this can sometimes contribute to the sense of pressure and claustrophobia I encounter when I am "in" my blog for too long. I do think it is particularly unique to blogging, myself, because part of this sense of immediacy (for me) is a sense of composing and communicating at the same time ("how will I communicate this ASAP in order to touch a nerve, please my audience?")

Thanks for this first post, and welcome, VM!

Mamma said...

Whenever I bring a camera to my eye I think about hearing someone once make the same point you make here.

I think there has to be a balance. If you drive to the ocean, get out of the car, take a picture and then turn around and head home to show off the picture to your friends, you never really saw the beach.

It's a combination of experiencing the event and capturing a piece of it for the memory that counts, right?

Now if it were only that easy.

Snoskred said...

As I type this, I have eight pre-written blog posts in a text folder. That text folder also contains about 20 little sentences - for example - consoling is not helping - and it did have about 6 blogging tips in there, which I just put together a post about. Once I've published the post, I delete the text.

I have notepads all over the place. The one by my bed contains words which I found while reading books and intend to make a blog post about words and definitions and how that changes (inspired by Jane Austen) over the years.

The one in my handbag says cryptically "kangaroo fox rabbit x2". The one by the TV has several thoughts on Shakespeare in Love, The West Wing and Desperate Housewives which shall all become blog posts one day.

I can take any of these and start composing on the spot, if I wanted to write something then and there. These days I am finding it easier to pre-write posts, editing them when I have a few spare minutes each day, and putting up the ones I feel are ready.

Today my cat was sitting in the shower, I grabbed some shots. As I did it I was composing the post - but the post won't appear until I have all the shots I want.

I even recently created a new art form in my blogging - blogging hands free. I had chores to do in the kitchen and I also had a blog post in my head screaming to get out. Solution - I grabbed the little tape recorder thing we had, spoke the blog post out loud while emptying the dishwasher and refilling it, and typed it up later when I got back to the keyboard.

I think writing is something you can learn, like any new skill. Unlike Julie, these are not things I have always done. Writing is not something that came naturally to me, but I look back at posts I made a year ago and wow, what a difference.

I even wrote a post about it :) 10 Easy Ways To Improve Your Blog Writing.

I think at the heart of it, this is simply us taking the stuff that goes on inside out head and making it presentable to others, communicating it, making people feel that "amen" factor.

If not for blogging, that stuff would just stay inside of us. Maybe we'd share some of it with family and friends, but not people on the other side of the world you've never met.

This is a very thought provoking post. :)

karrie said...

I caught myself becoming obsessed with the "I am so blogging this" behavior when I had a blog, and the realization that I was often orchestrating bloggable experiences instead of being present in the activity or moment made me very uncomfortable. It definitely factored into my decision to stop blogging--I just never sat down and tried to articulate it as you have here.



(Btw, I posted a nearly identical shot of a gnawed chocolate bunny this Easter, and it was one of those "oh, great blog fodder here!" shots)

karrie said...

Also wanted to add that I agree with the pps the nature of a writer is to observe, but the disconnection and sense that I was sometimes manufacturing experiences, troubled me.

Kvetch said...

As a writer and a blogger, I disagree.

I am more involved in my everyday and special day events and more enchanted and aware of the people in my life because I write. I want to experience things because that is what adds life to writing. I believe that if I'm with a group of friends, and something is happening that is worthy of a story, be an entire scene or a sentence, or a smirk -- as a writer I'm then drawn to look at the experience I'm having in many different ways so that it can benefit my writing today or in the future.

Writing makes me see my world from many angles, experience things from different points of view. Deciding how best - and if - to write something for a publication or a blog makes me think hard, and engage more. I tap into my observation skills and and my intuition.

For me, it's a good thing.

But years ago when my kids were young and I scrapbooked, I definitely planted strawberries with my daughter so I could make a planting strawberries page. I do understand. I stopped scrapbooking because that is what made me my own's life's spectator.

Returning to writing returned me to being a participant.

Megan/ Velveteen Mind said...

I agree with all of these perspectives. So much for controversy. ;) Unfortunately, I noticed that the name of this blog is not "Megan and Her Opinion in One Million Words or Less," so I figured I had better pick a side and stick to it.

I do think that this behavior is the nature of a writer, in general. I agree with gingajoy in that I think the immediacy of blogging adds another dimension to it versus writing for publication at a later date that would fall weeks or months from now.

Additionally, blogging as part of a conversation and identifying that "this is just what blogger x was talking about the other day" can contribute to that expanded awareness of your experiences.

In particular, I wanted to write more about what kvetch touched on, being the other side of the argument that blogging enhances our experiences. But again, I had to hop off the fence for the sake of the post. Years of debate ingrained in me still.

Oh, and the notebooks. Aah, the notebooks. The scattered pieces of paper on my desk, on the wall, in my purse. The snippets of blog posts spoken into my cell phone voice recorder while in the car. It's endless.

Lawyer Mama said...

Yes, I do it. But I've always done it. I've done it since I was a child. But, in my case, I think that the inner monologue helps me process things and figure out where I fit in. I just do consciously what most people do unconsciously.

This: "Something that might normally push you over the edge loses some of its own edge because you can see the humor in the situation, as it will be written." YES! That inner monologue helps me survive parenting. I think I'm a better parent because I consciously step back and try to see the humor in the drudgery of daily life.

Great post!

Christine said...

ok, today is my son's birthday and the pictures and the blog post i was planning for later really won't be the same. maybe that is a good thing.

Christine said...

ok, today is my son's birthday and the pictures and the blog post i was planning for later really won't be the same. maybe that is a good thing.

Stimey said...

I see myself in this post. Yet I agree with some of the commenters that I did this before I had a blog. I'm just happy to have a place to put my little mental compositions now.

Does it keep me out of the moment? I don't know. I have the notebook too, so I don't have to keep it in my head, because that's the part that (I think) takes me out of the moment: the remembering of specifics.

But the remembering of specifics is one very important reason why I blog.

But sometimes maybe I do take it too far. I posted a picture of my son's bloody toenail a while ago. And when I took the picture (specifically for my blog--I NEVER would have taken it otherwise), he said, "I wanted you to clean it, not take a picture of it."

Very interesting post.

Lara said...

bravo for capturing in words what so many of us experience. yes, i see the world around me so differently now, because i'm much more likely to think of how to write it or photograph it and share it with others. i'm not sure i think that's a bad thing for me, though. i'd say that i used to be a much more self-centered person, who just ignored most of the world around me. if it wasn't about me or for me, i just didn't notice.

while you could argue that my blog and my photographs are still "for" me, i'm a lot more likely (especially with the photos) to look to others now. i notice more of the world around me, even if in the end i'm still connecting it to my own experience. i find that i like living my life through that veil.

so far.

Gunfighter said...

I'm guilty.

I'm guilty and unapologetic.

Sue me... blogging is my fun. I think about it a lot. I'm on vacation at disney World, and I am so blogging about ALL of my vacation.

As a matter of fact, I think I am going to have a separate blog for my vacation report.

Tere said...

Great post! In my daily life, I don't think in terms of my blog. In fact, I sit back a lot and think, "What the H am I going to write about??"

But, there are definitely times when I catch myself thinking about how bloggable something is. A lot of it is when I'm out and about, as for some reason, that seems more interesting than my daily life.

And also, I compose posts in my mind - or at least, I'm almost always aware of the "need" to have something ready or drafted for when I can finally sit down and post it.

I echo Julie's comment in that even before blogging, I've been composing "posts" in my mind, also carrying my trusty notebook.

And yet, I'm conscious of the idea that my life could very well revolve around my blog, and I don't want that. On some level, I force myself to just live in the moment and worry about writing about it later.

My thoughts are scattered -- sorry, rough weekend!

mpearl said...

I do compose posts in my head just the way I might have a converstation in my head with someone. Yes, my headline on my blog is " I live in my head and need to get out". I think people who enjoy writing are always thinking of that story element in their lives. Writers are a form of reporters. We give a new take on what we see. I can even meet a person and think they would be a good character for a book, so why not for blogging.For me, blogging is a good thing, as long as I don't get too personal. My husband even commented that I am a happier person lately especially after I have been blogging or working on my writing.

Megan/ Velveteen Mind said...

I absolutely agree that blogging enhances our experiences, drawing us in to see a different perspective that we might not have otherwise taken the time to consider. However, even this weekend, I found myself distracted by blog posts floating around in my head, only to "tune back in" to what was going on around me. Ugh.

And yes, I absolutely did this before I had a blog, as well. I kept journals for about 17 years before I started blogging. However, the immediacy of this platform, particularly regarding feedback, changes it entirely.

I like mpearl's comment about her husband remarking that she is happier since beginning blogging. I think, again, that this brings us back to the perspective that it offers. Behind the veil, it buys us time to step back and see things in a different light.

Filtered through the veil, some of the sting is removed.

Oh, and Stimey, I love your bloody toenail example. Poor thing. Yet, these are my children, I'm sure... they just can't quite articulate it, so far.

thailandchani said...

As for the blogging, yes, it does keep me out of the moment. My posts are generally issue-based. I might hear something on the news or read something on another blog that generates a post on my blog.



Peace,

~Chani

Jennifer aka Binky Bitch said...

Well Megan, I love this post. Obviously I see myself in your words...I blog every experience, it's almost surreal since I can come unengaged from the moment. I suppose continual head dialogue has it's good and bad points. When Carson is taking a leak on the carpet after I just spent the day cleaning, blogging the experience in my head is a way to keep from getting *too* angry.

However, the bad side, I suppose, is that maybe I'm NOT fully involved in what's happening around me when I've got a running dialogue in my head. I've found myself tuning out a conversation or an interaction when I'm composing in my head. This is certainly NOT a good thing.

This view of life is new to me, as I never kept journals. However, like mpearl, I'm happier now that I blog. MUCH happier.

Deborah said...

So it's not just me???

Excellent post!

Corey~living and loving said...

What a great dialoge we have here. So much to absorb and think about.
I have wondered about some of this for some time. I am fairly new to blogging, and I dont' often find myself disengaging but I can certainly relate to the camera example. I blogged alittle about it a few months ago.
http://livingandlovingeveryminuteofit.blogspot.com/2007/05/peace-of-mind.html

On a whole I feel that blogging is helping me experience my life more. It is helping me sit back and look at the things I do or the things that happen and find the lesson in it. I think that is a very good thing.

Heather said...

Great post Megan!

I think people are rarely present in the moment anyway. I'm not sure blogging has changed that so much.

That's as deep as I can get today. But an awesome read!

Jen M. said...

This is a great topic. Twelve years ago I started scrapbooking (and left it pretty quickly) because I found that I was creating opportunities for the sole purpose of taking pictures to place in my scrapbook. My rock bottom was when I realized I had no "beach" page. So I packed up my baby and my two year-old and drove two hours to the beach. So that I could take their pictures and place them in their scrapbook. Pathetic.

Now my kids are at a Waldorf school, that prohibits cameras from school performances so that the parents might live in the moment. I think that's great advice. Blogging isn't so different.

Anonymous said...

I think people who have had life experiences that have forced them to live in the moment, do live in the moments they have. Sometimes hardships offer us the quickest route to our fullest lives. For me, blogging enhances experiences, it doesn't create them, or detract from them.

Maureen said...

Guilty as charged. But I did this before I blogged. For you see, I am also....

a scrapbooker.

I don't know how many times family / friends have quietly asked me "you're going to scrapbook this, aren't you?"

Of course I am. Someone has to be the preserver of memories in this family...

Moondance said...

I think it's a chicken and egg thing. Whether it's a handwritten diary with a lock you keep under your pillow and hope your parents don't find, or a blog, or a scrapbook, or photo album, I think the observer finds the medium as an outlet for his/her need to narrate life. When I was saving bits of ribbon and playbills and ticket stubs for my high school scrapbook, or remaining behind the camera at college parties, or looking at things through the veil of my blog, I was already that way, and the oulet did not CAUSE the disengagement.

I have often tried to live in the moment, but if I am not conciously forcing it, I slip back into it, and the blog/photo/scrapbook is merely a byproduct of my internal monologue.

I agree there needs to be a balance - thanks for bring this up so we can strive towards that balance if its what we need.

JenLo said...

That is the exact reason my husband will not read my blog. If you're not careful, everything that happens becomes "for an audience" and it takes the authenticity out of life.